News Summary
Deputy Chief James Dean of the Kansas City Fire Department plans to pursue legal action after being excluded from the fire chief selection process. Citing discrimination, Dean’s concerns led to city officials reinstating him in the hiring process due to media inquiries. Despite facing barriers with required certifications, he argues for fair consideration based on his extensive experience. Concurrently, Deputy Chief Laura Ragusa has also filed a lawsuit alleging gender discrimination, highlighting ongoing issues of diversity and representation within the department’s leadership.
Kansas City – Deputy Chief James Dean of the Kansas City Fire Department is threatening legal action against the city after being excluded from the selection process for the fire chief position. Dean, who is a high-ranking Black officer with nearly four decades of experience, has asserted that his exclusion from the hiring process is unjustified and discriminatory, and he plans to seek a court injunction if he is not allowed to compete for the role.
On June 16, Dean expressed his concerns in an email to city officials, indicating his intent to pursue legal recourse to halt the selection process. Just ten days following this communication, city officials reversed their stance, informing Dean that he would indeed be included in the hiring process. However, they cited a lack of specific firefighter certifications as the reason for his initial exclusion. These certifications, known as Firefighter I and Firefighter II, are now required but were not prerequisites when Dean joined the department in 1987.
In addition to these certifications, Dean’s emergency medical technician certification has lapsed, and this is now another requirement for the chief position. Despite these obstacles, Dean argues that it is only fair to include veteran members such as himself, particularly since these rules were not in place during their promotions. Dean also possesses two college degrees and has extensive experience in various leadership roles within the department, such as serving as an incident commander and overseeing minority recruitment. His contribution as the department’s safety chief further underscores his qualifications.
Recently, Teri Casey, the city’s Human Resources Director, communicated that the recruitment firm would provide an equivalency option for the Firefighter I and II certifications, thus possibly allowing Dean to qualify for the role. However, Dean and his legal team are also preparing to file a lawsuit related to a previous pause in the selection process that occurred over a year and a half ago, indicating a broader concern over procedural fairness.
Insiders suggest that Dean’s situation improved after media inquiries were made, as he received a prompt email from the city soon after the requests for information were communicated. Within the context of the selection process, Dean and another candidate, Deputy Chief Laura Ragusa, claim that their applications were intentionally sidelined to maintain the interim Chief, Ross Grundyson, who had been appointed temporarily. Dean contends that keeping Grundyson in place denies a fair opportunity to equally qualified candidates, particularly those from minority backgrounds.
Furthermore, Ragusa has taken legal action of her own, filing a whistleblower and employment discrimination lawsuit against the city, alleging gender discrimination in the hiring practices. Her claims highlight a troubling trend, as nearly all fire chiefs in the history of the Kansas City Fire Department have been white men, raising significant concerns about the representation and diversity within the department.
Historically, the Kansas City Fire Department has only had one Black fire chief, who served from 1980 to 1989, and the only female fire chief served for just over three years. This lack of representation has prompted Dean to emphasize the need for a more diverse leadership within the department, suggesting that systemic issues may be hindering capable Black candidates from advancing in their careers.
While the city has not commented publicly on the legal matters, a spokeswoman has remarked that the city is assessing the steps needed to resolve the situation. As scrutiny continues around the fire chief selection process, applications for the role were reopened after an earlier pause, with about 50 individuals having expressed interest by the June 10 deadline. Dean asserts that he and other qualified Black candidates were unfairly excluded from the first round of interviews, while Ragusa’s lawsuit underscores concerns of discriminatory practices based on gender. The developments in this situation will likely remain closely monitored as both candidates seek to assert their right to compete for the fire chief position.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Karrie Clinkinbeard Recognized as Top Business Defense Attorney
Kansas City Faces Delays in Clean Energy Funding
Additional Resources
- Kansas City Article 1
- Google Search: Kansas City Fire Department
- Kansas City Article 2
- Wikipedia: Kansas City Fire Department
- Kansas City Firefighters Training
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Firefighter
- Kansas City Settlement News
- Google News: Kansas City Fire Department
- Firehouse – Assault Case
